Showing posts with label peer feedback. Show all posts
Showing posts with label peer feedback. Show all posts

16 March, 2007

Podcasting to Improve Writing



EyePod (Revised)
Originally uploaded by LeggNet.
(Cross-posted from Beyond School)

Real quick: for the 1001 Flat World Tales project, we had each writer record and podcast him/herself reading the first draft for an audience of one: him/herself (gender pronouns stink).

Podcasting for self-criticism. I know it's not new, but it's so easy now. And it seemed to help the young writers hear the parts of their writing that needed improvement. Here's one student reflection:
The first thing came to my mind was that I had extremely simple and frequent grammar mistakes. I was kind of embarrassed when I heard it. Also, ideas and details sound incomplete and insights are shallow in depth; it was just shallow that proves not much thinking and brainstorming. I should work on 'showing' since my second draft 'told' everything. It sounded like a lecture about Korean cultures. Well, it was embarrassing to listen to my own podcast anyways.
It's all so easy now. Odeo, Podomatic. Students pick it up quickly, often without needing the teacher to know anything about it at all. How many teachers realize how easy it is to do this sort of thing?

Just thought it was worth a share.

(Photo credit: "EyePod (Revised)" by LeggNet on Flickr.)

13 March, 2007

Greenwich Time / UTC: The Next Shift?

Chris and Michele, I vote we all choose one Greenwich hour for revision deadlines and feedback deadlines. The initial confusion of learning to think in terms of a uniform "world time"--+9 for Seoul, -5 for Colorado (DST?), -8 for Hawaii--will clear itself up soon enough, and more than justify itself with the end of the deadline confusion and "false arrests" for "laziness" that I suspect we're all experiencing.

Seems like we want four days for revision, and for two of them to bet Saturday and Sunday. So I say revision should be due Greenwich Monday 0900. That makes your local deadlines in the States past Sunday midnight.

Deadlines for feedback would be three days later: GMT 0900 Thursday.

We can translate that to our kids so they all know what time that is locally.

But the point, again, is that everybody around the world knows the deadlines are at the exact same minute, regardless of local time. (In the military we called it "Zulu" time, if I recall correctly.)

Other teachers, I strongly suggest you adopt the same policy. The deadline confusion causes unnecessary confusion and frustration. Learn from our experience and save yourselves a headache!

Thoughts?

10 March, 2007

...And Student Empathy Too

Michelle's discussions were interesting to read and prompted me to add this post about my classes' Flat World Writing session yesterday (Thursday in Honolulu). We were working on feedback only. (Okay, now several anecdotes are popping into my head).

First, two students were sitting next to each other making their way through the organization rubric and their partners' stories. The first student's partner had not posted a second draft. So I asked if she put her partner's number and name on the 4th column. She said no. I asked why. She said that if her partner looked under history, she'd know who put her name up there, and she didn't want to make trouble (sorry for unclear pronoun references). So I asked her how she'd feel if she took my class, did no work, and I still gave her a passing grade.

Second, my other student was working on giving feedback on his partner's introduction. He was typing some rather discouraging and unhelpful notes. So I asked what his partner was supposed to work on after reading the feedback. And I asked him to rephrase his feedback according to Elbowing protocol. All of sudden, very useful feedback.
My observation is that because we don't share a physical classroom, each piece of feedback, every edit to the wiki carries more connotation. And that's a great exercise for students.

Finally, what's been really fun for my students are the two warm-ups that Clay created on the 1001 Writers blog. My students loved collaborating in a lower stakes activity. I think those really help trust/relationship building.

26 February, 2007

Podcast Part 2: More Conversation with Chris Watson

[From the Podcast notes on iTunes:]

Chris Watson, HS English teacher at Punahoe High School in Honolulu, Hawaii, USA, and Clay Burell of Korea International School in Seoul, Rep. of Korea, discuss the following topics in relation to their cross-world classroom collaboration on the 1001 Flat World Tales wiki world-wide writing workshop:
  • Student publishing process
  • Effective student blogging
  • Diigo
  • "This I Believe" podcast project
  • Informal Prof Devt through Skype
  • Using Library Thing for English classes
1001teachers: Chris Watson, part 2: Language Arts and the Read-Write Web


Click here to get your own player.

Eureka? A Solution to the Workshop Management Problem, I Think...

I just posted this on the HIGH SCHOOL 1001 Tales wiki discussion board. Short version:
  1. The workshop for this cycle is closed. Participating schools are Seoul, Arapahoe, Hawaii, and New Brunswick (Michele, Chris, Chad, and Me). THIS IS FOR HIGH SCHOOL ONLY. Other teachers in Middle School and Elementary, coordinate away and godspeed :P We're into week 2 of the writing process, and 131 students from four schools feels like the limit, coordination-wise. All other high schools planning to come in can collaborate in their own cycle based on their own time-frames. (And the door is open for interaction with the current students in some way. Thoughts?)
  2. The student writing links should not be edited by teachers or students anymore. There are three columns of 44 students. Each student can be assigned two students from the other two columns. Give the table a look and tell me if you think this works. We still need to coordinate which students are assigned to which rows. I vote that students do their own row this week, and go down one row for the next two students with each following week. Odds are, by the time the workshop is over, they'll get a good spread of feedback. Thoughts?
  3. This means that the peer assignments will be self-regulating from now on, if you agree. Otherwise, I see management issues continuing :( Thoughts?
Here's the msg from the discussion board:

Hi All,

I've reformatted the table for easy, self-regulating editing. The three columns allow each student in one column to peer feedback to two students from other schools.

Since we're now into the workshop, it makes sense to me (do you agree?) to close this workshop for this cycle. All future schools can collaborate with each other on their own time-frame in March or later (see the 1001teachers.wikispaces.com wiki for the Coordination Schedule, and find contact info for other schools there).

SO: INSTEAD of entering 50 or more names to the student link table, just assign your students to give feedback to the students in their own row this week (it's Monday, Feb. 26), in the row below them next week, the one below that the following week, etc.

If you can see a better system or want to disagree, please do! :)

I'm just trying to make this manageable. That's the one slice that needs an efficient solution.

Thoughts?

Clay

Coordination and Rotating Peer Assignments: Logistics

More: Chris and I discussed in the podcast how students should peer review different writers every week. I'm seeking a way to make it a self-running process, so we don't have to assign that every week.

I'm groping toward a solution, but could use help.

Michele D (Denver) and I originally paired students by ability groups: same-ability for one partner, and either +1 or -1 (in Vygotskian terms--"Zone of Proximal Development" and all that) for the other.

As new classrooms join, though, I don't see that being very possible. You?

My first groping (ouch) was just now: I added a lettered column "a-ff" to designate each row. I figure we might be able to say: week 1, do your own column and the one below you. Week two, etc.

But there are problems with that. Each column has different numbers of students in it. Maybe we should reformat? Thoughts?

I also numbered each student, 1 to 131. That gives us another option, since no number is repeated.

I don't have a good "logic puzzle" brain for these type things. If any of you do, I'm keen to listen. Because right now I have to assign the next teams for my students.

Learning is messy....

But this is so interesting.

Thoughts on Irresponsible Students: Three Strikes Policy?

More on the "Hall of Fame and Shame." The idea is this:

When students are assigned a writer to give feedback to, and find that the writer missed the deadline, I've directed my students to enter that person's name, school, and date in the "Hellooo?" table. I don't mean to be harsh, but I do mean to be real world: if students can't cooperate and be responsible, I vote we teach them a real world lesson by removing them from the project. Cooperative learning's dark side.

Otherwise, all others suffer headaches. Not fair. They'd be fired in the real world, so why not here? Let them do textbook exercises while everyone else connects to the world.

Similarly, with the "Your feedback made me ANGRY" column: two strikes and you're out? What do you think?

More positively, for the "You're a feedback STAR" column, I say bonus points for final project grade. Thoughts?

And what about the "You're NICE, but NOT HELPFUL" students? How deal with them?

I guess this all boils down to: how do we assess for cooperative learning/teamwork in this thing?

Thoughts? I'd say 10% of the final grade.

Oof! Trouble with Tables on Wikispaces (HELP!)

Oi vay. The good news, then the not-so-good news:

Good:
  1. In the past two days, the number of high school students in the 1001 Tales workshop has grown, with the addition of Hawaii and Canada to the pre-existent Denver and Seoul, from 107 learners to 131!
  2. I just added the "Peer Feedback Hall of Fame...and Shame" to the HS page (comments welcome).
Not-so-good:
  1. The new additions from Canada and Hawaii to the table was formatted wrong, and it took a good 1.5 hours to re-format. I know wikispaces tables are lame at this point, so here are some tips:
    1. add rows and columns by clicking in a cell and then clicking the formatting arrows that pop up.
    2. new rows are miniscule, but they're there. Tab from the end of a row with data in it to get into the nearly invisible row, and when you start typing it will expand.
    3. copy and paste of columns doesn't work. You have to enter info one cell at a time.
If you find that a table is messed up and you can't fix it, don't save it. Just cancel the edit and try again, using the directions above.

All that negativity aside, it's totally cool that we've grown so much in less than two weeks. Learning is messy :)

25 February, 2007

1001 Reflectors Podcast 1: Improving Peer Feedback in Writing Workshops, with Chris Watson

This is part one of a talk with Chris (more to follow). The following is from the iTunes podcast notes. Since this is an enhanced podcast, with timestamp and chapter headings, you may want to download it to your iTunes or other podcast aggregator. Happy listening!

Chris Watson, HS English/Language Arts teacher at Punahou High School in Honolulu, Hawaii, USA, joins fellow 1001 Flat World Tales collaborator Clay Burell of Seoul, South Korea, for a discussion about how to improve the tact, quality, and confidence of students giving peer feedback to other student writers during writing workshops. The first of a two-part podcast with Chris on the 1001 Reflections podcast series. Produced by Clay Burell for Beyond School and the 1001 Flat World Tales wiki/blog/"blook" k-12 world writing workshop. See Chris' excellent edublog, WatsonCommon, as well. Great stuff!


Click here to get your own player.